Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

Sunday, April 13, 2008

Ekalavya gets into a B-School...

We continue with our Parable of Modern-Day Ekalavya...

Thanks to the recent Supreme Court judgement, Ekalavya had applied and got into a B-school through the "OBC quota" seats

...and immediately hit the glass ceiling described as "Criteria specified in Category VI" in the Supreme Court judgement!!

He could get the admission, because he had qualified, because he belonged to the "reserved" OBC category, and because he did not belong to the "creamy layer" criteria specified in the judgement.

His parents did not fall in the categories of Constitutional Posts, i.e.,

  • President of India
  • Vice-President of India
  • Judges of the Supreme Court and of the High Courts
  • Chairman and Members of UPSC and of the State Public Service Commission
  • Chief Election Commissioner
  • Comptroller and Auditor-General of India
  • Persons holding constitutional positions of similar nature as above

    He was also not the progeny of those falling into the Service Category or the category of Armed Forces including Paramilitary Forces, i.e.,
  • Class I & II officers in Central or State services
  • Class I & II officers who may have expired or suffered permanent incapacitation, but had the benefit of employment in any International Organisation like UN, IMF, World bank, etc., for a period of not less than 5 years, prior to that.
  • Employees in Public Sector Undertakings
  • Officers holding equivalent or comparable posts in PSUs, Banks, Insurance Organisations, Universities, etc. (and also to equivalent or comparable posts and positions under private employment, pending the evaluation of the posts on equivalent or comparable basis in these institutions)
  • Persons who hold the rank of Colonel and above in the Army and to equivalent posts in the Navy and the Air Force and the Paramilitary Forces

    In any case the above would not have qualified for reservations due to the "Criteria specified in Category VI"...
    (yes, yes, I am coming to what this criteria is... Let there be some suspence to the story! ;0)

    This "Criteria specified in Category VI", however, did apply to the sons and daughters of other categories.

    For instance, it applied to sons and daughters of Professional Class and those engaged in Trade and Industry, e.g.,
  • Persons engaged in profession as a doctor, lawyer, chartered accountant, income tax consultant, financial or management consultant, dental surgeon, engineer, architect, computer specialist, film artists and other film professional, author, playwright, sports person, sports professional, media professional or any other vocations of like status
  • Persons engaged in trade, business and industry

    ...and it also applied to the progeny of the Property Owners, e.g.,
  • persons belonging to a family (father, mother and minor children) which owns only irrigated land which is equal to or more than 85% of the statutory ceiling area (which is 25 acres), etc.
  • owners of coffee, tea, rubber,mango,citrus, apples, etc., plantations
  • owners of vacant land and/or buildings in urban agglomerations
    etc.

    But, what was this "Criteria specified in Category VI"?

    This was the final "Income/Wealth Test", meant to exclude the "creamy layer" - it excluded people coming from families with sufficient financial means. Based on the famous Indra Sawhney (Mandal) SC Judgement, this criteria excluded sons and daughters whose parents had an annual income of more than Rs 2.5lacs (Rs, 250,000).

    Happily and fortunately, this criteria, which would have excluded him from admissions, did not apply to Ekalavya. He did not belong to the "creamy layer". His parents did not hold Constitutional Posts, or were in the Service Category. They were also not in the Professional Class, or engaged in Trade and Industry, with an annual income exceeding Rs 2.5lacs. And, of course, they owned no property, as described in the judgement.

    But Ekalavya was crestfallen and dejected - actually shattered - when I met him.

    "There is no way, I can get into this B-School," he told me.

    "But why?", I asked him. "You have qualified, and you are not in the "creamy layer"."

    "But where will I get the money to pay the fee?"

    "What's the problem?", I said. "You can get education loan from a bank, can't you? Everyone says how simple education loans are nowadays. And you can pay that back once you get the job. Look at the average B-school salaries these days!"

    "But do you know? The IIMs almost doubled up their fee just a week before the Judgement." he spat. "It is close to Rs 10lacs now... Other will follow soon, I am sure."

    "How does that matter to you?", I could not comprehend. "What is Rs. 10lacs? You can get the education loan, and pay it back when you get the job. After all, your salary package will compensate for the fee hike."

    "Yes, this is what everyone tells me. Once in the job, you can easily cover your costs." he said. "But you need money to get into, and through, a B-school, don't you?."

    It was then that he shared the glass ceiling - or the Combo of B-school Fee Hike and India Banks' Association's Model Education Loan Scheme for Pursuing Higher Education in India, which is followed by all banks with minor modifications.

    "Not being from the "creamy layer"", he said, "I need to take a loan of at least more than Rs 7.5lacs (The max recommended limit is Rs 10lacs) to pay the fee. I also need money to live and eat during those two years. But that loan requires as, the document says, "co-obligation of parents together with tangible collateral security of suitable value"."

    tangible collateral security of suitable value!! What is that!!?

    I read through the Model Education Loan Scheme about the collateral security. It read:
    "The security can be in the form of land/ building/ Govt. securities/ Public Sector Bonds/Units of UTI, NSC, KVP, life policy, gold, shares/mutual fund units/debentures, bank deposit in the name of student/ parent/ guardian or any other third party with suitable margin."

    Ekalavya glared at me. "Please tell me,", he challenged. "...all you who keep talking about "creamy layer". I am not the "creamy layer" and therefore, I am entitled to what you call "reservations". But also because I am not the "creamy layer", the banks would not give me loan to see me through my education."

    No! I have no anwers for Ekalavya. Maybe only a solace that, OBC or not, - on the income criteria - more than 95% people in this country do no belong to the "creamy layer"!

  • Thursday, April 10, 2008

    "Alternative Perspective" on Reservations/ OBC/ Merit/ Quota/ Discrimination, etc

    Today the Supreme Court gave the verdict upholding the 27% reservations for the OBCs in IITs, IIMs and other Central educational institutions but excluded the creamy layer (i.e., the children of constitutional functionaries including the President, judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts, members of the Union Public Service Commission, Groups A and B or Class I or II officers of the All-India Central and State services and children of public sector employees) from the benefit.

    Just thought it appropriate to share the past 14-15 postings on:

    Alternative Perspective on Reservation, meritocracy, OBC quota, etc.
    (click to access)

    To me, rightly or wrongly, this makes perfect sense... After all, you have to change the system to change the human dynamics in that system.

    However, lest the "manufactured merit" churned out by the coaching centers feel that "their" rightful seats (due to the freak circumstances of their birth, and the coaching institutes) are being taken away from them, here is a clarification:


      "In the 2007-08 budget, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram allocated Rs.26.98 billion for central educational institutions under the HRD ministry providing for 54 percent increase in the number of seats.

      According to officials, in the budget for 2008-09 an allocation of about Rs.25.22 billion has been made for central universities - IITs, IIMs, NITs etc, for the purpose.

      Following protests from various quarters, an Oversight Committee recommended a 54 percent expansion (over three years) in central educational institutions so that the number of general seats is not reduced."

    The SC judgement vindicates what Michael Young - who coined the term Meritocracy - wrote in 2001 (I had quoted it earlier):

      "It is good sense to appoint individual people to jobs on their merit. It is the opposite when those who are judged to have merit of a particular kind harden into a new social class without room in it for others.

      Ability of a conventional kind, which used to be distributed between the classes more or less at random, has become much more highly concentrated by the engine of education.

      A social revolution has been accomplished by harnessing schools and universities to the task of sieving people according to education's narrow band of values.

      With an amazing battery of certificates and degrees at its disposal, education has put its seal of approval on a minority, and its seal of disapproval on the many who fail to shine from the time they are relegated to the bottom streams.... The new class has the means at hand, and largely under its control, by which it reproduces itself."

    Saturday, October 27, 2007

    Ekalavya Applies for a Job!!

    Let's suppose the modern-day Ekalavya is able to convince the Dronacharyas, manages to get into a decent educational institution, does well in his/her study (or as well as the modern-day Pandavas)...

    Or alternatively, the Swaminomics' suggestion that "creating quality schools and colleges for dalits and tribals would be a far better form of affirmative action than job reservation in the private sector", gets implemented, and so Ekalavya goes through this special institution to prepare him/her to join the mainstream society with adequate "merit"...

    ...and then applies for a job!

    Chances are that s/he will find that the world has still not changed - not for him/her.

    These are the findings of a recent study, which was done by the Indian Institute of Dalit Studies (IIDS) and Princeton University:

    "The researchers filed 4,808 applications for 548 jobs advertised in English newspapers over 66 weeks starting October 2005. Applications by equally-qualified males from higher upper castes, Dalits and Muslims were filed for each vacancy and the response from the corporate sector was shocking.

    While all higher upper caste candidates were called for interviews for a particular job vacancy, only 67% Dalits and 33% Muslims were contacted."


    The study, original paper published in The Economic & Political Weekly (Oct 13, 2007) mentions the methodology:

    "The research staff prepared sets of three matched application letters and résumés (in English) for each type of job. These applications had identical educational qualifications and experience. All the résumés and cover letters presented strong applicants for the job opening: they had suitable degrees from reputable universities...

    The only aspect of family background that was communicated in these applications was the applicant’s name, yet this was enough to generate a different pattern of responses to applications from Muslims and dalits, compared to high caste Hindu names. These were all highly-educated and appropriately qualified applicants attempting to enter the modern private sector, yet even in this sector, caste and religion proved influential in determining ones job chances...
    These discriminatory outcomes occurred at the very first stage of the process that Indian university graduates go through to apply for a job...."


    Another recent study by S Madheswaran and Paul Attwell - Cast Discrimination in Indian Urban Labour Market (Economic & Political Weekly, Oct 13 2007) - concluded:

    "...(a) discrimination causes 15 per cent lower wages for SC/STs as compared to equally qualified others; (b) SC/ST workers are discriminated against both in the public and private sectors, but the discrimination effect is much larger in the private sector; (c) discrimination accounts for a large part of the gross earnings difference between the two social groups in the regular salaried urban labour market, with occupational discrimination – unequal access to jobs – being considerably more important than wage discrimination – unequal pay in the same job..."

    So what is the future for Ekalavya?

    Pretty bleak, actually! - because even in the unlikely scenario of enforced job reservations in private sector, Swaminomics recommends the tactics for "Getting Around Job Quota", e.g.,:

    "Faced with job quotas, companies could stop outsourcing and resume in-house operations. They can hire dalits and tribals as sweepers, canteen workers, drivers, chowkidars and so on.... They can open holiday homes for officers in the hills, employing tribals. This will enable them to fulfil job quotas without affecting management or factory quality."

    This, perhaps, also represents the distorted definition of Enlightened Self-Interest in a divided society.

    Wednesday, June 27, 2007

    Not "just another brick in the wall"

    Jaideep Sahni has this very interesting piece of Op-Ed in June 24th TOI. Some excerpts:


      I was fifteen years old when I was asked to decide what I was going to do for the rest of my life. I’ve often wondered at the stupidity of this — how can a 15-year-old possibly make such a decision? The second thing I’ve never understood is the way I was asked. I was asked to choose the direction of the rest of my life from science, commerce and arts. Can all the millions of wonderful options in life be classified into three things? Just 15 and they have already shrunk your life....


    ....So what am I doing writing movies and lyrics in Mumbai? Well, before I started writing screenplays and songs, I used to make ad films, before which I used to be an IT consultant for big corporations. That’s the point: I might want to make movies, write computer software, design embedded systems for public utilities, write songs, learn how to fly planes, turn FM radio on its head, and a zillion other things. But does my education give me wings to fly, explore, change course?... why is it so detached from our dreams? Why didn’t I have the option to dabble in a wide variety of subjects while in college, so I didn’t have to spend a large part of my working life searching for what I really loved?

    I’ve always had this funny suspicion that we are a nation of engineers who wanted to be singers, doctors who wanted to be actors, and so on. This is partly because we are a poor country and everybody makes life decisions based on how much he will be able to earn. And partly because nobody ever advised us any better. And that has made us a weird society. A nation which at all times is running on half-steam because a huge percentage of productive citizens are just passing time — because they’re not doing jobs they’d really like to do.

    ....Our schools lock children up in private little hells where they learn the fear of failure and the fine art of travelling through airless cells called careers where we spend the rest of our lives racing each other to places we never wanted to go in the first place. "

    Wednesday, June 13, 2007

    Inequality has many faces...

    Though P Sainath's article is about CEOs and the Wealth of Notions, but what struck me was this portion.

      "This week's big news is that Mumbai has topped Maharashtra's HSC results with a pass percentage of 76.67. That should not surprise us. The metro's schools and facilities outclass those of other regions. True, even this time, the State toppers are not from Mumbai. They are from Wardha (in Nagpur division) and Amravati. Both in Vidharbha. But at 47.5 and 51.08 per cent, the overall pass percentages of those divisions are dismal. They are way below the State average of 64.25 per cent. And both have fared worse than they did last year.

      Here's one reason why. Vidharbha, always electricity starved, saw 12- to 17-hour power cuts at the time the children were studying for their examinations. (It's a region where schools re-open weeks late to avoid exposing children to excessive heat.) The great metro of Mumbai was spared this "power crisis." (Some of the well meaning did write articles on how to be a good citizen and use your air conditioners more efficiently.) In one estimate, a 15-minute power cut in Mumbai could give Vidharbha two hours of electricity. Half that would have helped the students with their examinations. Further, malls and multiplexes lead Mumbai's biggest power guzzlers. But this is the city of 25,000 of India's 83,000 dollar millionaires. Not only home "to the largest number of affluent individuals," as an American Express study puts it. But also having "the fastest growing affluent population in the world." So the darkness is banished to zones such as Vidharbha — which produces more power than the other regions of Maharashtra.

      ....That rubs in an old truth. Merit = accident of birth + electricity. (And maybe a dash of geography.)
      "
    It is an appropriate example of the skewed distribution of opportunities, of how inequalities - and "merit" - get created.... of the suicidal "siphoning-up" economy we live in...

    Cross-posted at: How The Other Half Lives

    Sunday, May 13, 2007

    Divided by "English"

    It is pardoxical to write this post in English....

    India consists of some 18-22 scheduled languages... A tower of Babel!

    One of its strengths is also its "large English-Speaking" population (but then, in India everything is large due to its size and proportion... where else on the planet, will one call a population on 120mn people - twice the size of the population of many countries - a "minority")

    But, the "large English-Speaking" population, actually consists of around just 30-40mn people (out of 1bn+)... These are the people who can read-write-speak "English". The others have there own version of "Hinglish", e.g.:

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    (Photo Credit: Unknown)

    One of the assumptions one makes as an educated, urban Indian is that it is the size of the "large English-Speaking" population that gives India an economically competitive advantage over other countries in the world in this globalised world. It also leads to some other implicit assumptions, e.g.,

  • "good" education gets equated with English-education

  • English is seen as essential for higher studies in engineering, medicine, science, social science, management, etc.

  • knowledge of English becomes a symbol of sophistication, of being cultured, and even of intelligence (or as the term currently in vogue, of "merit")
    Etc.

    And as happens with deeply cherished and widely shared social assumptions, they get enacted in the "real" world, shape the social reality, and become a self-fulfilling prophesy - i.e.,

    because
    ...teaching in higher education is done in English, selection tests are designed in English, job interviews are conducted in English, candidates get selected on the basis of their knowledge of English, etc.,
    therefore
    ...more technical books are written/published in English, there is greater demand for learning in English (or more number of shops that teach "English speaking"), knowing and conversing in English becomes "smart", "cool", "in" etc...

    It is in this context, Sankrant Sanu's post on the "The English Class System" is worth looking at (actually, recommended!)

    The following two tables are from his post, and show that:

    Rich countries are more likely to speak their native language:
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic


    ...while the poor countries adapt their "colonial" language:
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic


    I don't think that, based on this data, one can generalise that speaking the language of one's past colonial rulers makes a country poor. However, the fascination with English (or the colonial language) among the poor (and mostly post-colonial) countries does explain the historical antecendents of the linguistic divide between the "haves" and the "have-nots" of these societies. As Samuel Huntington had noted:

    "As the former colonies moved towards independence... promotion and use of indigenous languages... was one way for the nationalist elites to distinguish themselves from the Western colonialists and to define their own identity. Following independence, however, the elites of these societies needed to distinguish themselves from the common people of their societies. Fluency in English, French or another Western language did that. As a result, the elites of non-Western societies are often better able to communicate with Westerners and with each other than with people of their own societies..."

    And so - among many other divisions - India also remain "divided by English"... There are "English-haves" and "English have-nots"...

    ... Or as, in an earlier post about Garima's story, I had quoted from an article by Barkha Dutt:

    "...Garima’s story exposes India’s paradoxical relationship with the English language. Nobody in the world speaks English like us. We have our own idioms, our own words and our own accents.

    We pretend to love our own English and brag about how it is India’s great selling point; the reason we dominate the global outsourcing business. But, of course, deep down we know that our English is not the English that the West really wants. And so, each time we talk to Britons or Americans, we subtly alter our diction and inflection. When we set up our call centres, we drop the subtlety entirely and start accent classes to teach our young people to abandon the speech patterns of our own society and to migrate to a virtual, linguistic, middle America, where they become impersonators of people they will never meet and never know.

    But within India, we still treat our own English as the great social decider. We laugh at regional accents, smirk at those who make grammatical errors and feel most at home with those who talk like us. Everyone else belongs on the other side of the English divide. And as it turns out, the other side of the class and caste divide as well."

  • Sunday, April 22, 2007

    Manufacturing "Merit" - Part 2

    It was in the context of "reservations" and "merit"... Some months back, one of my posts on this blog/newsletter "Manufacturing Merit" had mentioned:

      "....to win in this Darwinian landscape, an entirely new industry has taken shape during last decade or so, which specialises in "Manufacturing Merit"...the "Coaching Institutes"...

    ...which help aspirants to "crack" the entrance tests for any of the premier engineering/business institutes - irrespective of their basic undestanding of the subject...

    The post ended with my understanding of the scenario:

      "From a purely socio-historical point of view, the coaching institutes, in a very short period of time, have revolutionised two major changes in the societal texture of India:

      1. they have redefined and evangelised a new meaning of "merit", which is essentially based on the supply-demand gap of opportunities in the society, and

      2. they have successfully created a small but vocal new "social class" which owns the "merit" (and its definition) in the society."

    Thanks to Abi's post about Bashing the JEE of IIT today, I accessed the Outlook aticle "Coaching Factories Are Dumbing Down The IITs"

    ... and it was heartening to see that this manufactured "merit" is loosing its shine...

    The article starts thus...

    • Tata Steel MD, B. Muthuraman, an IIT Madras graduate, says IITs are now thriving on their "past reputation" and TISCO is "not likely to recruit" IIT graduates any longer

    • Many IIT professors too find the present crop of students lacking in creativity, and the spirit of innovation and inquiry

    • They blame the students' blinkered, robotic approach to their studies on the fact that a large majority are products of coaching factories.

    • They call for reform of the joint engineering exam (JEE), and of the IIT curriculum as well, to develop the students' societal awareness, communication skills and knowledge of the humanities.

      The nearly 2.5 lakh students who wrote the Joint Entrance Exam (JEE) a few days ago for the 4,600 seats across seven IITs were blissfully unaware of a simmering debate about the JEE system, the institutes' curriculum and their future employability. What has triggered the discussion within the fraternity is the concern expressed by two distinguished IIT alumni about the general decline in standards of excellence at the institutes in recent years. Their remarks have questioned the calibre of students who make it into the IITs by subjecting themselves to the killing rigours of coaching factories in places like Kota and Hyderabad. The alumni seemed to conclude that these products of coaching factories—who now form, according to Wikipedia, 95 per cent of students at IITs—had a blinkered approach to education, did not recognise new ideas and had lost the spirit of inquiry and innovation...

    ... which brings one back to the issue of "Merit" vs. "Reservations"...

    or as this article so succintly puts it:

    When excellence in the IITs today is more in the imagination than in reality, how could reservations further erode it?

    I guess, it will make as much sense if one replaces "IITs" with "IIMs" and "JEE" with "CAT/XAT/MAT, etc."...

    Saturday, January 20, 2007

    On Merit & Discrimination: Pygmalion in the Classroom

    In 1960s, Robert Rosenthal, currently a Professor of Psychology at Univ of California, along with and Lenore Jacobson had conducted a series interesting experiments about what a teacher - and his/her beliefs, hopes, biases and prejudices - can do to a student.

    The findings of their unsettling study finally got published as a book: The Pygmalion in the Classroom
    ...and have been replicated more than 350 times since then....

    The experimental design was simple:

    Randomly select a groups of students, and group of teachers. Tell the teachers that they are going to teach some of the brightest of the brains in the school.

    The Result: The students out-performed their batch, even though they had no "real" differentiating "merit".

    Rosenthal's studies were about the schools, so one issue that begged the questions:
    does this apply to higher education?

    Apparently, it does, as he shared the example of the juniors he teaches:

      "I ask them to define a research problem, search the literature, design an experiment and come in with results all in one semester. Now nobody can do all that in one semester. I can't do that in one semester, but these are juniors: they don't know it can't be done; so they all do it. They do amazing things."
    The reverse of this self-fulfilling prophesy was also true - i.e., if the teachers perceived students as below average, their perfomance was also below average...

    Some other later studies also identified the reasons for such perceptions (which are quite relevant to contemporary Indian acadmic environment) for such perceptions - and therefore, lower performance among students:


  • Sex. Lower expectations are often held for older girls--particularly in scientific and technical areas-- because of sex role stereotyping.

  • Sociao-Economic Status. Teachers sometimes hold lower expectations of students from lower SES backgrounds.

  • Race/Ethnicity. Students from minority races or ethnic groups are sometimes viewed as less capable than Anglo students.

  • Type of School. Students from either inner city schools or rural schools are sometimes presumed to be less capable than students from suburban schools.

  • Appearance.The expense or style of students' clothes and students' grooming habits can influence teachers' expectations.

  • Oral Language Patterns. The presence of any nonstandard English speaking pattern can sometimes lead teachers to hold lower expectations.

  • Messiness/ Disorganisation. Students whose work areas or assignments are messy are sometimes perceived as having lower ability.

  • Readiness. Immaturity or lack of experience may be confused with learning ability, leading to inappropriately low expectations.

  • Halo Effect. Some teachers generalize from one characteristic a student may have, thereby making unfounded assumptions about the student's overall ability or behavior.

  • Seating Position. If students seat themselves at the sides or back of the classroom, some teachers perceive this as a sign of lower learning motivation and/or ability and treat students accordingly.

  • Negative Comments about Students. Teachers' expectations are sometimes influenced by the negative comments of other staff members.

  • Outdated Theories. Educational theories which stress the limitations of learners can lead to lowered expectations.

  • Tracking or Long-Term Ability Groups. Placement in "low" tracks or groups can cause students to be viewed as having less learning potential than they actually have.

    Rosenthal's book ends with a quote from GB Shaw's play "Pygmalion":

      ..."You see, really and truly, apart from the things anyone can pick up (the dressing and the proper way of speaking, and so on), the difference between a lady and a flower girl is not how she behaves, but how she's treated. I shall always be a flower girl to Professor Higgins, because he always treats me as a flower girl, and always will; but I know I can be a lady to you, because you always treat me as a lady, and always will."
    ...perhaps - as the so-called "issues" of reservations, quota and merit, etc. become increasingly a reality in India - Rosenthal's studies put the issue/choice in a nutshell:

    It all depends on....
    How do you treat Eliza Doolittle?
    ... As a "lady" or as a "flower girl"?!!!

    Sources:
    Rosenthal Lecture
    Expectations & Student Outcomes
    Pygmalion In The Classroom
    "Proper" English & Reservations-of-a-Different-Kind
    Quota/Reservations: More ""Reserved" than Others
  • Tuesday, June 27, 2006

    "Proper" English & Reservations-of-a-Different-Kind

      A couple of years back, an alumnus who had graduated more than 30 years back from the B-School where I teach, had shared a personal episode with me. After joining the institute, within first term he realised that he could not cope up with the place. This was not so much because of the academic pressures, but because all teaching was done in English, and he was not at all conversant in the language.

      Deciding to call it quits, he went to the then dean, and told him about his decision. "But you can't leave just because you don't know English!!", the jesuit priest told him... and then spent next six months, daily two hours, teaching him English!

      When I met him, he had already worked with some of the leading Indian and foreign corporates for a couple of decades, had raised a family of very mature children (I met them), had decided to branch out on his own, and was operating his business.

    Why did I recall this incident today?
      ...Today, I chanced upon a report (tip: Uma's blog) about Garima, the 16-year old daughter of a Delhi police constable, who had topped her class X (in the government-aided DAV Dwarka) by securing 97.6% marks in the CBSE exams - and a perfect 100 in science. Belonging to one of the Delhi villages, when she applied to DPS Dwarka (New Delhi), she was not selcted.

      According to the school principal: "This year, we had around 200 applications for 28 seats. In the admission process, the Board exam score is not ignored, neither is it the only criteria. We take in students on relative merit, on the basis of an entrance test, an interview, and the board exam marks."

      Garima ranked 12th out of 80 students selected in the written test, and made it to the interview, where she failed to make the grades. DPS' explanation for rejecting her was: "The CBSE marks don't mean anything to us. We have certain criteria about the kind of children we want. She wasn't able to speak English properly and that was also a problem."

      There were 9 other girls who got selected, though they had less marks in CBSE than Garima, but fitted the "kind of children" the school wanted.

      Garima was lucky, since she got noticed by the media and appeared on NDTV debate. Barkha Dutt wrote about her: "...there was nothing about her spoken English that suggested that she would have been unable to keep pace with the syllabus. Yes, she spoke with a regional accent that some would consider insufficiently sophisticated. But there was no doubt that she could not only follow a complex argument, she could also make herself understood to any English speaker."

    I think, and hope, that Garima's case is not generalisable across all schools and all people. There are some heart-warming exceptions too. For instance, there was this touching article on Sudama's Children in the recent issue of The Outlook, which featured the Delhi schools and childen from less-privileged backgounds who studied there... about their challenges and the support they got from their peers and school.

    Neverthless, Garima's case does open up three issues to think about...

    1. The Purpose of Our Elite Educational Institutions
    Whether DPS - or IITs, NITs, IIMs, XLRI, etc. - the entry to all such institutions is based on criteria that select the "educatable" students. These are the one who meet the criteria - good "background", the "profile", "communication skills" (in "proper" English) - that will help them to do well at the exit stage (e.g., cracking the IIT, B-school entrance test, getting a "good" job, etc.). This 'exit performance', in turn, increases the equity and ranking of the institution, and will attract more of such people to the educational institution.

    Needless to say, such institutions do add value by polishing the latent aptitudes of the students.

    But do they really create value which contributes to society?...

    ...or to paraphrase Justice Chinnappa Reddy 1985 SC judgement:

  • is it greater value to sharpen the aptitude of "the children of the upper-classes who go to St. Paul's High School and St. Stephen's College, and who have perhaps been specially coached for the examination may secure 70, 80 or even 90 per cent of the marks"

  • or does one create new value by bringing those chidren into the mainstream of the society, who have "no books and magazines to read at home, no radio to listen, no TV to watch, no one to help him with his homework, whose parents are either illiterate or so ignorant and ill informed that he cannot even hope to seek their advice on any matter of importance."

    [Barkha Dutt's article - The English Divide - articulates the other two issues much better, and so, I will take the liberty of quoting from her]

    2. The "Meaning" of Merit in Our Society?
    "Garima’s story is a metaphor for India’s twisted tryst with the future... For some months now, as the debate over reservation has raged, opponents of the quotas have made the same point again and again: we should be a society where merit matters. It’s a compelling argument... But what do the anti-quota street fighters have to say now? Here’s a girl who competed in the mainstream, her own DAV pitched against the trendier, richer, big names. But her merit was swallowed up by prejudice.

    ...and all because her English accent was not sufficiently sophisticated!!!

    3. "English" as an Instrument of Social Divide?
    This is an important aspect of our social divide, since in India - inspite of its much touted "large English speaking population", there are barely 20-40mn (out of 1bn), who can actually read, write and speak English (of course, we have our own form of "Hinglish" with the road-side dhabas advertising that they serve "snakes" (snacks) with "child bear" ;0)...

    ...and there is an "elitism" about speaking "proper" English - even though, our English acquires its own regional peculiarities across the country.

    As Burkha Dutt, points out:

    "...Garima’s story exposes India’s paradoxical relationship with the English language. Nobody in the world speaks English like us. We have our own idioms, our own words and our own accents.

    We pretend to love our own English and brag about how it is India’s great selling point; the reason we dominate the global outsourcing business. But, of course, deep down we know that our English is not the English that the West really wants. And so, each time we talk to Britons or Americans, we subtly alter our diction and inflection. When we set up our call centres, we drop the subtlety entirely and start accent classes to teach our young people to abandon the speech patterns of our own society and to migrate to a virtual, linguistic, middle America, where they become impersonators of people they will never meet and never know.

    But within India, we still treat our own English as the great social decider. We laugh at regional accents, smirk at those who make grammatical errors and feel most at home with those who talk like us. Everyone else belongs on the other side of the English divide. And as it turns out, the other side of the class and caste divide as well."


    Sources:
  • Did you say merit?
  • DPS turns down CBSE topper
  • The English Divide
  • Sudama's Children
  • Schools shouldn't hold interviews after boards: CBSE chief

  • Sunday, June 04, 2006

    Meritocracy & the "Secession of the Successful"

    This is a continuation of my previous post about Manufacturing "Merit"...

    According to Wikipedia:
    "Meritocracy is a system of government based on rule by ability (merit) rather than by wealth, race or other determinants of social position.... Meritocratic governments and organizations stress talent, formal education, and competence, rather than existing differences such as social class, ethnicity, or sex. In practice, research on social mobility indicates that all these supposedly neutral criteria favour the children of those who are already privileged in some way."...

    The term "Meritocracy" was coined by a British sociologist Michael Young in his 1958 novel The Rise of Meritocracy. Ironically, Young had coined the term in a disparaging sense to describe an unstable society in which one's social place is determined one's IQ. In the novel, this social system led to wide disparities between the masses and the elites, who had become arrogant and disconnected from the public sphere... And ultimately, to social revolution in which the masses overthrew the elite

    Much later, the Harvard Professor, Richard Reich, coined the term "Secession of the Successful" in a 1991 New York Time article to describe how the elite "become arrogant and disconnected from the public sphere"



    In a recent HT article, Sagarika Ghose captured the meaning of "Secession of the Successful" quite graphically:

    "the ‘successful’ tend to ‘secede’ from society as they get richer and more successful. That is, those who are successful tend to retreat into a totally private world. They use private electricity. They attend private schools and colleges. They live in private colonies, manned by private security guards. They socialise at private clubs, use only private transport and thus they cease to have any stake at all in the ‘public realm’ or in the public world."

    Perhaps most insightful are these excerpts from Michael Young's 2001 The Guardian article about merit and meritocracy:

    "It is good sense to appoint individual people to jobs on their merit. It is the opposite when those who are judged to have merit of a particular kind harden into a new social class without room in it for others.

    Ability of a conventional kind, which used to be distributed between the classes more or less at random, has become much more highly concentrated by the engine of education.

    A social revolution has been accomplished by harnessing schools and universities to the task of sieving people according to education's narrow band of values.

    With an amazing battery of certificates and degrees at its disposal, education has put its seal of approval on a minority, and its seal of disapproval on the many who fail to shine from the time they are relegated to the bottom streams.... The new class has the means at hand, and largely under its control, by which it reproduces itself."

    Tuesday, May 30, 2006

    The Merit of Reservations

    Is there a merit in reservation?

    In fact, as many comments on the previous posts allege, the benefits of reservations are supposed to have been cornered by the "creamy layer" or by those who don’t actually fit into the criteria of being "backward".

    On the other hand, a nation cannot develop on a sustainable basis, unless certain radical reforms are implemented to tackle the issues of social disparity and unequal opportunities...

    The arguments on both side (pro- and anti-reservations), however, are largely based on ideological and/or anecdotal evidence.

    My own mental analogy has been like this: if you spray fertilizer in a field - real life not being 100% perfect - it will not only help some plants to grow and bloom, but will also kill some plants due to overdose, and it will also often facilitate the growth of the weeds for whom it was not meant...

    But the effectiveness of the fertilizer is if the aggregate productivity of the field increases.

    And so, in this current debate about the reservations, one of question begs the answer:

    Is there any empirical evidence to show that quota has really helped?... And if they have not done so far in last 60 years, how can one be sure that they will do so now?

    The Southern Four states (Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, and Andhra) have had 50% or more reservations in higher and profession education for many decades - even before the Mandal Commission in late 70s.

    If the distributive justice that the reservations aimed at really worked, then there should be some aggregate positive differences between the Southern and the Northern states.

    In one of the earlier postings (pt.10), I had quoted how in Tamil Nadu (which has had 69% reservations since 1960s), in 2004, students belonging to the Backward Class (BC) or Most Backward Classes (MBC) quailified for 952 of the total 1,224 seats in 12 government medical colleges in the State (77.9 per cent), and the first first 14 ranks in the medical admissions went to BC/MBC students.


    But, as one would point out, getting into a medical college through reservation, is very different than becoming a good doctor (or as someone cruelly commented: "would you leave your life in the hands of a SC/ST/OBC doctor who got into the profession through reservations?")

    Following this line of enquiry, I stumbled upon this report on The Merits of Reservations. It is based on the data from the Planning Commission's National Human Development Report 2001:

    As the table below shows, apparently, at an aggregate societal level, reservations in healthcare education have had a positive impact on the society:



    Sources:
  • Merits of Reservation
  • Planning Commission's National Human Development Report, 2001
  • Southern Solitude
  • Reservations/Quota and the Meaning of "Merit"

  • Monday, May 29, 2006

    Who are the OBCs?...

    It is surprising - or perhaps not so, given the "uneducated literacy" in the country - that a large number of people on either side of the reservation debate have little idea about the definition of OBCs.

    This results in, e.g., a false debate on whether the reservations should be based on "economic criteria" or "caste".

    Most people don't know - or care to find out - that the very definition of OBCs, however, was/is not based on genetic heredity. Rather, it is based on multiple criteria which consider not just the social (or caste-based) deprivation, but also on educational and economic deprivation...


    According to Mandal Commission:

    The backward Castes/Classes were defined on the following 11 criteria:

    A. SOCIAL

  • Castes/classes considered as socially backward by others.

  • Castes/classes which mainly depend on manual labour for their livelihood.

  • Castes/classes where the percentage of married women below 17 is 25% above the state average in rural areas and 10% in urban areas; and that of married men is 10% and 5% above the state average in rural and urban areas respectively.

  • Castes/classes where participation of females in work is at least 25% above the state average.

    B. EDUCATIONAL
  • Castes/classes where the number of children in the age group of 5 to 15 years who never attended school is at least 25% above the state average.

  • Castes/classes where the rate of student drop-out in the age group of 5-15 years is at least 25% above the state average.

  • Castes/classes amongst whom the proportion of matriculates is at least 25% below the state average

    C. ECONOMIC
  • Castes/classes where the average value of family assets is at least 25% below the state average.

  • Castes/classes where the number of families living in kachcha houses is at least 25 % above the state average.

  • Castes/classes where the source of drinking water is beyond half a kilometer for more than 50% of the households.

  • Castes/classes where the number of the house-holds having taken a consumption loan is at least 25% above the state average.


    According to National Commission for Backward Classes:

    The commission, after studying the criteria/indicators framed by the Mandal commission and the commissions set up in the past by different state Governments and other relevant materials, formulated the following guidelines for considering requests for inclusion in the list of Other Backward Classes:

    A. SOCIAL
    1. Castes and communities, generally considered as socially backward.

    2.
  • Castes and communities, which mainly depend on agricultural and/or other manual labour for their livelihood and are lacking any significant resource base.

  • Castes and communities, which, for their livelihood, mainly depend on agricultural and/or other manual labour for wage and are lacking any significant base.

  • Castes and communities, the women of which, as a general practice, are for their family’s livelihood, engaged in agricultural and/or other manual labour, for wage.

  • Castes and communities, the children of which, as a general practice, are, for family’s livelihood or for supplementing family’s low income, mainly engaged in agricultural and/or manual labour.

  • Castes and communities, which in terms of caste system, are identified with traditional crafts or traditional or hereditary occupations considered to be lowly or undignified.

  • Castes and communities, which in terms of the caste system, are identified with tradtional or hereditary occupations considered to be ‘unclean’ or stigmatised.

  • Nomadic and semi-nomadic castes and communities.

  • Denotified or Vimukta Jati castes and communities

    3. Castes and communities, having no representation or poor representation in the State Legislative Assembly and/or district-level Panchayati Raj institutions during the ten years preceding the date of the application
    (The term “poor representation” may be taken to refer to a caste or community whose presence in the body is less than 25% of its proportion in the population.)

    B. EDUCATIONAL
    1. Castes and communities, whose literacy rate is at least 8% less than the State or district average.

    2. Castes and communities of which the proportion of matriculates is at least 20% less than the State or district average.

    3. Castes and communities, of which the proportion of graduates is at least 20% less than the State or district average.


    C. ECONOMIC
    1. Castes and communities, a significant proportion of whose members reside only in Kachha houses.

    2. Castes and communities, the share of whose members in number of cases and in extent of agricultural lands surrendered under the Agricultural Land Ceiling Act of the State, is nil or significantly low.

    3. Castes and communities, the share of whose members in State Government posts and services of Groups A & B/Classes I & II, is not equal to the population-equivalent proportion of the caste/community.

    Moral of the Story:
    Intellectual brilliance/moral superiority is not a substitute for ignorance of facts ;0)

  • Friday, May 26, 2006

    Quota/Reservations: More ""Reserved" than Others

    Suddenly, the "OBC reservations" has opened the Pandora's Box.

    The popular view (among the urban middle-class educated people) is that "quota" is bad - and dilutes the "merit"...

    Frankly, I also became aware of the various kinds of "quotas" that exist to access the "temples of higher education" in India across the states. Most have been accepted (er...why???) as a given - and, to my knowledge no candle march or hunger strike ever took place against these!!

    ...that is, till the "OBC quota" came up, and opened a Pandora's Box.... here is a list:

  • All India Quota

  • State Quota: varies upto 25%... that allows one to skip the all India "merit" criteria and get an admission due to domicile status. It is not very difficult to get the domicile certificate, really;0)

  • Management Quota: around 15%.... Govt/ SC has been trying to squash it, but it still does give one an opportunity to get into an un-aided private college - if one can pay the money!

  • NRI Quota: small in number but allows one to slip past the criteria of "merit" if some rich relative abroad can sponsor one's education

  • Sportsman Quota, Army Quota, etc.

    The Quota Trophy, paradoxically, goes to AIIMS:

    While the AIIMS medicos go on hunger photogenic strike against the "reservations" (what with celebrity endorsement from Nafisa Ali and Shiv Khera)... there is no mention that 25% seats in the AIIMS PG course are "reserved" for AIIMS graduates).

    Just quoting from a news item in TOI:

    "25% reservation that AIIMS graduates get in PG admission and the Supreme Court judgment of 2001 that declares the earlier system of 33% reservation for them bad in law...

    The HC had found that "AIIMS students, who had secured as low as 14% or 19% or 22% in the (all-India) entrance examination got admission to PG courses while SC or ST candidates could not secure admission in their 15% or 7% quota in PG courses, in spite of having obtained marks far higher than the in-house candidates of the institute." HC had analysed admission data over five years.

    The apex court also agreed with the HC that the "figure of 33% reservation for in-house candidates was statistically so arrived at as to secure 100% reservation for AIIMS students. There were about 40 AIIMS candidates. The PG seats being 120, 33% thereof worked out to be 40." That meant all 40 AIIMS graduates were assured of PG seats.

    Merit here was clearly being sacrificed, the study showed...

    ....Twelve AIIMS candidates were selected even though they got less marks than the SC candidate who secured 60.33% marks. Similarly, 16 AIIMS students got admission to PG courses even though they got less marks than another ST student who got 62.16%.


    Etc.

  • Monday, May 22, 2006

    Reservations/Quotas and the "Meaning of Merit"

    If you are reading this posting on the blog or on a mail, then perhaps 90% chances are that you are against the "reservations" on the ground that it dilutes the "merit".

    This, perhaps, is less indicative of the popularity of the "merit-cause", and more of the the fact that the Indian blogger community/netizens represents a self-reinforcing socio-politically isolated section on the other side of the digital divide.

    In a democratic set-up, one is naturally entitled to have his/her own viewpoint... So this posting has nothing to do with being "for" or "against" the reservations... To each his own!

    This posting is about some simple facts which somehow are never quoted/known in MSM - and about which few Indian bloggers ever bother to check/find-out...

    ...and to explore that if "merit" is the issue, then what does "merit" mean in the urban-centric visible India.

    So if you happen to be one who is agitated and angered about the additional 27.5%reservations/quota in the "temples of higher education" (e.g., IITs, IIMs) - and how it dilutes the "merit"... Then please be honest - and answer in Yes/No

    Did you know that...

  • 1. The announcement by Minister for HRD, Arjun Singh, that "government is considering reservations in all educational institution" was based on the 104th Constitutional Amendment Bill, passed by the Lower House of Indian Parliament (Lok Sabha) on Dec 21st, 2005, by 379-to-1 votes (381 present, one abstained).
    Yes / No?

  • 2. It was also passed by the Rajya Sabha by 172-to-2 votes.
    Yes / No?

  • 3. The Bill was signed by the President of India, APJ Abdul Kalam, on Jan 20th, 2006 - thereby making it the 93rd Constitution Amendment Act, 2005, to be enacted upon by the incumbent government.
    Yes / No?

  • 4. There is no Mandal-I or II!!! (as projected by the media)... The proposal for this Amendment was based on Indian Consitution, and came from the recommendations of Mandal Commission - which was formed in 1978, during Janta Party regime, and submitted its report in 1978-79.
    Yes / No?

  • 5.According to findings of the Mandal Commission, in India there are (or were at that time) more than 3,000 OBC castes that constitute about 52% population of India (see the figures below)- these are in addition of 16% SCs and 8% STs. Together - SCs, STs & OBCs - constitute 76% of India's population.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    .
    Yes / No?

  • 6. Besides the reservations, the Mandal Commission also recommended a number of other things - about which neither the media nor the "pro-merit" citizens are either aware, or willing to "protest" about, e.g.:
    - radical alteration in production relations through progressive land reforms
    - special educational facilities to upgrade the cultural environment of the students, with special emphasis on vocational training
    - separate coaching facilities for students aspiring to enter technical and professional institutions
    - creation of adequate facilities for improving the skills of village artisans
    - subsidised loans for setting up small-scale industries
    - the setting up of a separate chain of financial and technical bodies to assist OBC enterpreneurs.
    - increasing the seats in institutes of higher education to accommodate the "reserved" candidates", etc...
    Yes / No?

  • 7. According to the Mandal Commision recommendations, the increase in reservations should be only along with the increase in the seats in the institute, i.e., the "reservations" should not have an adverse impact on regular non-reserved category. For instance, IIM-C and IIT-Kharagpur have already decided to increase the seatsYes / No?

  • 8. Notwithstanding the claims that the increase in seats to accommodate the "reserved" candidates, requires enhancement of educational infrastructure (hostels, faculty) - which it is claimed will strech the capabilities of the institutes and impact their "quality" - the professional institutes (IIMs, XLRI, IITs, etc.) have continued to increase their seats over last 4-5 years.
    Yes / No?

  • 9. Large number of Indian Institutes of higher education charge (or used to charge, till the Supreme clamped down) "capitation fee" - i.e., allowing a "quota" for those who can pay. Similarily, there are "reserved" seats for foreign nationals, who pay higher fee in $s, even if they don't meet the criteria of "merit".... But no protest/"candle-march" ever happened against this "dilution of merit".
    Yes / No?

  • 10. The four Southern States - Kerala, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, and Andhra - have had around 50% (or more) reservations for last 2 to 4 decades in their institutes of higher educations (Tamil Nadu adapted 69% reservations even before Mandal Commission; Kerala had 50% reservations since 1970s, etc.). These reservations/quota cover some of the prestigious universities like Anna, Tiruchi, Bharthidasan, Osmania, etc. (This, apparently, has not diluted the "merit" coming out from these "temple of higher learning").
    Yes / No?

  • 11. In 2005, in Tamil Nadu (which has 69% reservations for BC and MBCs since 1960s), the first 14 ranks in the admissions to the 12 state government medical colleges, went to the OBCs... In fact, among the top 400, only 31 were from the "forward class", and the Backward and Most-Backward class students qualifed for 952 out of 1,224 seats (78%).
    Yes / No?

  • 13. In old times, the lower classes (shudras) were not allowed to enter the temples, and were even punished to hear the vedas?
    Yes / No?

    Now, just in case, one did not know these (or most of these) facts - even though one felt angered by the dilution/pollution of "merit" by the "reservations" - then there is a point to consider:

    Does "merit" in modern educated urban India mean being totally oblivious and alienated from the current socio-political reality?... and remains confined to proactive action only under threats to "my job, my merit.... my lollipop!"?

    Or, in other words:

    Is the anti-reservations sentiment among the educated urban Indians merely a morally justifiable "rang-de-basanti" peg on which one can hang one's sulking tantrums about the loss of monopoly on the traditional turf?

    POST-SCRIPT: May 27th, 2006:
    I had never thought that this isolated posting on the "meaning of merit" will bring so many bouquets and brickbats;0) - thanks to all who visited and contributed ... And instead of responding in the comment section (see below), I thought it may be worth adding this postscript as a response.

    So here goes...

    In the present zeitgeist, it is so easy to fall into "for us"/"against us" kind of binary thinking. The issue, at least to me, is far more complex than yes/no kind of classroom quiz. That is why the statement: "this posting has nothing to do with being "for" or "against" the reservations...", and focus was on the unmentioned facts in the MSM (and, unfortunately, also in the popular blogosphere).

    Unfortunately, there are still many pieces of mis-information floating around (as can be seen in the comments). And this post-script is just to further clarify (and to highlight the ignorance about facts in the public domain):

  • Contrary to popular belief/knowledge, the Mandal Commission's definition of OBC was based on 11 criteria, which covered Social, Educational and Economic discrimination. Thus, the debate about "caste-based" vs "economic criteria" is actually a non-issue!!

  • The National Commission for Backward Classes, which was established in 1993 after the Supreme Court judgement about the "Creamy Layer", also uses Social, Educational and Economic criteria to identify backward classes

  • While it is true that that the last caste-based census was held in 1931, the Mandal Commission (and before that, Kaka Kalelkar Commission, 1961), had based their recommendations on their own sample surveys - one may have disagrements about the sample survey methodology, but it is not true that these reocommendations were based on 1931 data!

  • The differences in the estimates of OBCs among different surveys (52% by Mandal Commission, 32% by NSSO, 29% by National Family & Health Survey, etc.) is not because one is more accurate than the other - but because each uses difference criteria to define OBCs.

  • I would agree that any policy (reservations, 'tatkal sewa' in railways, tax-concessions/breaks to certain sections in the society, etc.) would seem unfair if considered only in the context of isolated individual cases ("my job, my merit..."). The real critreia of "merit" lies in the ability to see it in larger context of a society and history.

  • Personally, I can't understand the issue about the "vote-bank politics";0) - In a democratic society, all decisions will be invariably "political" and influenced by the votes of the constituents. This would apply as much to the "reservation" issue, as well government's decision to invest in urban infrastructure, opening of FDI in different sectors, etc.... But I guess, interpretations differ depending one's own stakes.

  • Sunday, May 07, 2006

    Global Illiteracy & the "Global War on Terror"

    The findings of the National Geographic-Roper Survey 2006, conducted by the National Geographic Society, were released on May 1. The survey explored the Geographic Literacy among young Americans (age 18-24).

    Key Findings:

  • 63% percent of Americans aged 18 to 24 failed to correctly locate Iraq on a map of the Middle East.

  • 70% could not find Iran or Israel.

  • 90% couldn't find Afghanistan on a map of Asia.

  • 54% were unaware that Sudan is a country in Africa.

  • 48% of young Americans believe the majority population in India is Muslim.

  • Though they were aware of the devastation caused to Indonesia by tsunami in Dec'04, Three-quarters of respondents failed to find that country on a map. And three-quarters were unaware that a majority of Indonesia's population is Muslim, making it the largest Muslim country in the world.

  • Fewer than 20% young Americans own a world map.

  • Fewer than 30% think it's absolutely necessary to know where countries in the news are located.

  • Only 14% believe speaking another language fluently is a necessary skill.

    The geographic knowledge about US itself was just as much dismal:

  • Half could not find New York State on a map of the United States.

  • A third of the respondents could not find Louisiana, and 48 percent couldn't locate Mississippi on a map of the United States, even though Hurricane Katrina put these southeastern states in the spotlight in 2005.

  • Told they could escape an approaching hurricane by evacuating to the northwest, only two-thirds could indicate which way northwest is on a map.

    ...Which reminds one of the "foreign affairs quiz" to which George W Bush was subjected to during his campaign during 1999. The following is the transcript of Q&A between reporter Andy Hiller, and the then-presidential candidate, George W Bush:

    Hiller asked: "Can you name the president of Chechnya?"

    "No, can you?" Bush replied.

    "Can you name the president of Taiwan?" Hiller asked.

    "Yeah, Lee,'" responded Bush, referring to Taiwanese President Lee Teng-hui.

    "Can you name the general who is in charge of Pakistan?" asked Hiller, inquiring about Gen. Pervaiz Musharraf, who took over last month in a military coup.

    "Wait, wait, is this 50 questions?" replied Bush.

    Hiller replied: "No, it's four questions of four leaders in four hot spots."

    Bush said: "The new Pakistani general, he's just been elected – not elected, this guy took over office. It appears this guy is going to bring stability to the country and I think that's good news for the subcontinent."

    Hiller persisted, saying "Can you name him?"

    Bush said: "General. I can name the general. General."

    "And the prime minister of India?" asked Hiller, inquiring about a man who was recently re-elected and who last year tested a nuclear bomb.

    Bush said: "The new prime minister of India is – no."

    At that point, Bush responded in kind to Hiller.

    "Can you name the foreign minister of Mexico?" asked the governor, whose home state borders the Central American nation.

    The reporter replied, "No sir, but I would say to that, I'm not running for president."

    The Roper Survey perhaps explains why he got elected.

    To understand the implications for those not living in US, of this chemistry between the Leader and the Led, one must watch these two video-clips (humorous but also disturbing):

    On the Streets of America (1)

    On the Streets of America (2)

  • Sunday, May 22, 2005

    The Maya of B-School Salary

    Yesterday, I received this interesting mail from a student, who will be joining the XLRI course this June:

    "I will be joining XLRI for 2005-07 batch in PM&IR . I wants to know if is there a basic difference between the salaries for BM students and PM&IR students and if you can kindly tell me the average salaries for PM&IR and the prominent companies coming to the campus for PM&IR."

    While such a curiosity can be considered natural, there were two things about the mail which struck me:

    One, the subject of the mail was "urgent"... I wondered if he needed this information to take an immediate decision - and how would this statistical information really help in taking a personal decision, and

    Two, this was the only query in the mail... no other questions, e.g., about the nature of jobs one can expect, what skills would be required, or what one can expect in the 2 years of coursework... It was almost as if after getting the offer for admission, the only worthwhile issue to consider is the salary one can expect after two years.

    ...this stimulated some thoughts about this obsession with salary, and salary statistics being being considered the primary criteria for ranking of education in B-Schools. The summary of those reflections:

  • Mostly the salaries quoted by the companies are not the ones which the B-School grad gets in hand. Since late 90s, companies started packaging their salary offers under a mysterious heading of CTC (Cost-to-Company). I consider it "mysterious", because calculation of CTC is actually more an art than a science. Anything can become a part of CTC...

    Many companies add the induction training cost to their CTC (e.g., if part of your training includes a one month "foreign" assignment, it is bumper addition to CTC - besides of course adding the "foreign" glamour to the job offer); some others also add the cost of subsidised lunch in the canteen in the salary package (e.g., you pay Rs 10, while it costs company Rs 150/-, and so, Rs 140/day get added to CTC). Similarly, stock options, market value of chamari accommodation, medical insurance entitlement (e.g., if one is insured for Rs 2lac by the company, that also goes into calculating the entitlements), etc. - or even the market value of infrastructure provided to you (office space, PC, etc.) can be - and sometimes are - part of CTC... A few years back, one MNC bank had given an offer of Rs. 9.0 lacs/annum to one of the students; of which Rs 6.0 lacs was for the rental value of a flat in Malabar Hills, which the bank was providing for her accommodation!!!
    (to be fair, now many companies do share both the CTC and take-home salary, but somehow the CTC occupies a larger mindshare)

  • Why do companies do this? Why not be just straightforward and realistic in quoting the salaries? One reason, of course, must be the economics of recruiting, i.e., apparently the person does "cost" them that much. But a more likely reason is the implicit knowledge that salary is the only (or at least the main) criteria which a young B-school graduate considers in deciding on a job... In fact, as the mail above indicates, it is often the main criteria for even joining the B-School in the first place.

    Moreover, it is very rare that a student has actually studied the company s/he is applying for, for the job - information about the company is normally gathered through pre-placement talks (which most B-school students abhor to attend, and which often also present a pretty white-washed picture of the company), through feedback from their seniors who may have joined those companies, or through their own, or their batchmates', summer training experience in that company. Sometimes, the media reports (including the Best Employer Surveys, Best Place to Work, etc.) - specially, those published during last one years - also play a role.

    But ultimately, the choice is determined by the salary package, since, under the peer-pressure during the "Placement Season", the salary also becomes a - one may say, the only - measure of one's self-worth.

  • The myth of CTC-masquarading-as-high-salary, however, does not end here. It gets further perpetuated by the B-Schools themselves, when they quote salaries for the subsequent B-Schools Ranking Surveys done by different magazines and newspapers. Ostensibly, it is done to create awareness about the institute, and to maintain/build the institute's "brand" so that it can attract better recruiter (who quote higher CTC/salary), and better prospective students (who aspire for higher CTC/salary)... I am not sure if rankings also attract better faculty to join the institute...

    All B-Schools regularly highlight the highest salary offered to students, the average salary, number of "foreign placements", average number of job offers per student, etc. (I am always intrigued about the speed with which the calculations of "average salary" are made, within hours of the finishing of the placement - and weeks before the actual job-offer letters, which give the real break-up of salary, reach the students). In recent years, other statistics have got added to this list - e.g., how quickly the placement got over. Earlier it used to be calculated in number of days, nowadays it is quoted in "hours" - mostly indicating a change in method of calculating these figures!!.

    Needless to mention, no B-School shares information about the "lowest" salary, or the "average salary of the bottom 30%", or about the number of students who did not get placed (even in cases when this happens: a few years back, one of the premier B-Schools, which had a large batch-size - about 300 - and was left with about 25-30 students without a job offer. It gave temporary jobs of "research associates" to all of them, so that it could declare 100% placements in record time!!!)...

  • Lastly, we have the magazines and newspapers, who play a crucial role in sustaining, and feeding, the illusions.

    Why do these publications neglect other data - e.g., lowest salary - in their survey?

    One simple reason is that they are entirely dependent on the B-Schools themselves for any information - and no B-school will share this kind of information (or, at least, will share it accurately). Secondly, to do an accurate survey of hundreds of B-schools requires resources - reporters who can travel to the business schools, talk to recruiter, alumni etc. - which will make the cost of the "story" prohibitive. In fact, often the survey is outsourced to some other agency.

    This often makes the validity of information on which the survey is based, somewhat questionable (a year or two back, in one of the surveys, the publication also wanted to include "alumni rating" as a dimension. Naturally, it asked the B-schools to get survey forms filled up by a sample of their alumni... Well, the rest can be guessed!!!)

    One must also mention that conducting B-School ranking survey, by itself, has emerged as an effective business-model for increasing circulation of any publication (and the huge ad-revenue it generates - virtually, all B-Schools issue ads for these special issues).

    Correspondingly, there are some 6-7 B-School Surveys, conducted each year by different magazines and newspapers - each uses different methodologies, evaluates the B-Schools on different set of criteria, and each claims to be the "most comprehensive and accurate"!!!... Not many people notice this, but even for the same publication, the survey methodology and ranking criteria keep on changing from year to year!!!... it is almost like being ranked on your height one year, and on your weight the next year, making it impossible to compare rankings of a B-school across years, even on the surveys conducted by the same publication.

    ... An indicative example of the 'objectivity' of survey was the one done by a well-known global marketing agency for a certain well-known business magazine in 2003. On page 46 of that magazine was the description of the methodology. It read:

    "It is based on (the agency's) trademarked xyz-Model, and it involves a perceptual survey of (list of dimensions)etc. By not depending on questionable factual information, and focusing exclusively on subjective information, the (magazine's) survey ends up being most objective of them all."!!!! [no, I am not joking or making it up - this is a verbatim quote!]

    Not surprisingly, the ranking of the same B-School on different surveys can vary from being among top 10 to being relegated to something like No. 47...

    [These lacuna would perhaps also explain why this year, the IIMs announced that they will not participate in any survey... Or why Harvard and Wharton had withdrawn from the Business Week survey last year]

    In any case, by and large this "model" works: the implicit collusion among the recruiters, B-Schools and the media helps "manufacturing" a reality which suits all the three players....

    ...and who loses in the process?

    ...the naive prosective B-school aspirant - the kind, who wrote me that mail yesterday...

    ...till s/he joins the system, and becomes a party to creating/ perpetuating the Maya of B-School Salary....

    Other Related Readings:
  • The Real Salaries in B-Schools (archived discussion board)
    http://www.pagalguy.com/cat/archive/index.php/t-2195.html

  • There's many a pay slip... (EcoTimes)
    http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/46792795.cms

  • What ails Indian B-school education
    http://us.rediff.com/money/2005/mar/16guest1.htm

  • The $150,000 googly
    http://youthcurry.blogspot.com/2005/03/150000-googly.html

  • Get the best salary for yourself
    http://in.rediff.com/getahead/2005/mar/03gd.htm

  • Disclosure!!! (coolavenue)
    http://www.coolavenues.com/placements/2004/disclosure.php3

  • IIMs shun business school surveys
    http://in.rediff.com/money/2005/mar/31iim.htm

  • IIMs should not shun surveys
    http://in.rediff.com/money/2005/apr/13iim.htm

  • Monday, April 05, 2004

    IIM, the accidental brand

    This is an interesting perspective...


    http://in.rediff.com/money/2004/mar/23iim.htm
    March 23, 2004


    Which side are you on in the IIMs versus Murli Manohar Joshi battle?

    Personally, I am on the side of the spectators, who are getting their money's worth of action and drama, despite competition from cricket and politics. I find it difficult to root for one side or the other because neither has earned it.

    In any controversy of this kind, the easy thing to do is to let the combatants define the issues and then allow ourselves to be persuaded by one argument or the other. But the real issue is different.

    Ask yourself: which side has actually done something to further the cause of management education? That is the side worth backing. Arguments about fees and autonomy are red herrings.

    If I may oversimplify things for a moment, the broad objectives of management education should be to develop competent managers to run various kinds of institutions (profit-oriented corporations, non-profits, government and social sector organisations) and create intellectual capital through cutting-edge research that can influence practice. There can be several other objectives, too, but these are certainly the most important.

    In these two crucial tests, the IIMs -- and other B-schools in India -- have flunked. As their financial backer, the government shares the blame in equal measure.

    True, we have corporates willing to pay IIM-brand MBAs lakhs of rupees merely for passing out of these institutions. But is that success? Contrary to popular impression, the IIMs do not produce great managers; it is cut-throat competition for IIM seats that ensures high-quality MBAs.

    On the other hand, given the amount of government funding received by them, the IIMs have been complete failures: they have not produced the kind of managers we need to run government or social sector organisations. Nor have they produced a single piece of research that can be called cutting-edge.

    My argument is that the reputation of the IIMs has been built on the quality of its students and alumni -- not the other way around. This fact can be easily checked out: Indians with means would anyday opt for a Harvard or Wharton -- and they would even find it easier to get admissions.

    If at all the IIMs need to be complimented on anything, it is the huge entry barrier they have put up to prevent average students from getting in.

    So, if I were Murli Manohar Joshi, I would cut off all IIMs from any government grants for failing to do what they are supposed to. And if I was on the other side -- a dean or chairman of an IIM board -- I would say that the objectives of management education cannot be met within the limits set by government babus -- and would walk away to set up fully private or charitable institutions that would train the right kind of managers for different kinds of institutions -- for-profit or non-profit.

    And if I were a corporate, I wouldn't look beyond the CAT preparatory schools for recruits. If you merely want candidates who have the right mental skills for success, a CAT ranker is as good as an MBA -- and without the arrogance.

    Why wait two years for him to earn an MBA, spend another year teaching him business realities, and live all the time with the fear that he may abandon ship at the slightest opportunity?

    Groups as big as the Tatas or Birlas may actually find it cheaper to put candidates through simple IQ tests, organise customised learning on the job and create an internal campus where the faculty would be a mix of in-house managers and academics who understand the Tata or Birla ethos.

    Such students would also come cheaper, since they would not have wasted two years trying to acquire an MBA that's far removed from reality. I wouldn't be surprised if many corporates start thinking along those lines shortly. The growing popularity of executive MBA programmes is a foretaste of things to come.

    Quite clearly, if the IIMs and other B-schools are to be relevant at all in the Indian context, they have to reinvent themselves. They are succeeding today only because the people who buy their products -- corporates, primarily -- are too lazy to do the job themselves.

    Seen in this perspective, it matters little whether the IIMs charge Rs 30,000 per annum or Rs 1.5 lakh. Either way they don't produce the kind of managers India needs.

    Equally, it matters little whether the IIMs are autonomous or not. They have done little with whatever autonomy they had so far. The unvarnished truth is that the IIM brand was not the creation of a far-sighted government or of the people managing these institutions.

    It was an accident resulting from the sheer quality of students getting in. The issue before both the government and the faculty is simple: accident or otherwise, they have a good brand on their hands. Should they acknowledge their undeserved good fortune and make joint efforts to make the IIMs really worthy of their reputation or should they destroy it, since they did little to create it anyway?