This morning I had an egg for my breakfast along with my customary glass of milk…. And it suddenly dawned on me how this innocuous act must have added to the food inflation, as the "storyline" from the top brains and policy-makers in the government has been pointing out during recent months (guiltily, I also recalled having fish on last Tuesday :((
“What prices are going up are those of vegetables, eggs, fish that are secondary and tertiary food items. That is a reflection of the demand for these commodities exceeding supplies... That in turn, to some extent at least, is a sign of growing prosperity of our country.” - Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in Cannes (November 8)
“Food inflation is still going high. It’s dangerously above the double-digit figure. This is the effect of festive season demand. November onwards, the trend for the remaining four months (of the fiscal) would be available.” - Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee (November 3)
"…food inflation (can be explained by) somewhat less known Bennett's Law which says that as incomes go up, people eat less of serials and eat more of protein and which is what we are seeing in India happening today. Protein food inflation was evident even earlier, but it has been much sharper in recent period reflecting among other things accelerated increase in nominal wages.” - Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, D Subbarao (Nov 22)
“High inflation number points towards people eating healthier food, better lifestyles.” - Chairman of the Planning Commission Montek Singh Ahluwalia (Jan 20, 2011)
“Food habits of people are changing. Their purchasing power is up. This is causing food inflation. They are consuming more milk and eggs, so why blame the government?” - Union Food Minister K V Thomas (Oct 29, 2011)
…meanwhile, I recall reading a in a report that during last 3 years, the retail price of sugar has risen by 100%, wheat by 150%, lentils by 300% and vegetables by 300% - and one of GOI’s own report mentions that per capita availability of grains has decreased from 163kg to 161kg per annum during the past decade or so.
…though that is another “story”…
Saturday, November 26, 2011
How my breakfast caused "food inflation"!!
Posted by
madhukar
at
Saturday, November 26, 2011
0
comments
Labels: Hunger, India, Inequality, Poverty, Suicide Economy
Thursday, July 15, 2010
Guns and Daughters
Glimpses of lives, torn in what someone has described as "India's very own civil war" - where some are drawn unknowingly into taking sides, and some make a conscious choice....
...but as this documentary by Shikha Trivedy says:
"...today there are ideas of many India at war with each other. And in any war, women are the worst off..."
Posted by
madhukar
at
Thursday, July 15, 2010
1 comments
Labels: Dispencible People, Freedom Suppressed, India, Inequality, terrorism
Saturday, May 01, 2010
International Labour Day - The Forgotten Story
I had a vague idea about the origins of the "May Day"/ "Labour Day" (but not much) - besides of course that it coincided with some of the pre-Christian pagan festivals in Europe...
So, today when one of my senior colleague, who has spent more than four decades dealing with Industrial/Labour Relations, both as a practicing manager and then as an academic (besides being the author of "one of its kind" book on Industrial Jurisprudence, sent this mail, I thought that this forgotten history is worth sharing. I am reproducing his mail below:
--------
Today is celebrated as a "Labour Day" all over the world. Quite a few of us may not be knowing "why May 1st only"; "why not some other day"; and "why at all should there be a special day of commemoration for working class"? Here is the story in a nutshell.
Explitation by US Industry - Long Working Hours
There was no law in US in the19th century (and until even as late as 1932), which conferred a right on the working class to form a union. Secondly, any attempt of workers to organise themselves was considered "criminal conspiracy" attracting prosecution under the criminal law of US. Thirdly, the US industry was guilty of forcing the workers, including women and children to work for long hours stretching to 15 to 18 hours a day.
Anarchist Movement - Strike by 400,000 Workers in Chicago on May 1, 1886
This was the state of affairs which prompted a few workers called as "anarchists" to secretly organise workers in Chicago in 1886 demanding "8-hour workday". The first strike in this regard was in McCormick Harvester Company, on 1st May 1886, in which workers of other industrial units numbering some 4 lakhs joined, sending shivers down the spine of business captains and the government. Police entered the fray leading to violence (including the throwing of a bomb by anarchists at the police party with the latter opening fire killing and wounding a few hundred protestors.
Trial and Execution of Seven Union Leaders
Finally, police picked up eight men stood trial for being "accessories to murder". They were: Spies, Fielden, Parsons, Adolph Fischer, George Engel, Michael Schwab, Louis Lingg and Oscar Neebe. The trial commenced on June 21st 1886 in the criminal court of Cooke County.
The trial was whimsical and wishy-washy in so far as no evidence was offered that any of the speakers had incited violence and indeed, in his evidence at the trial, Mayor Harrison described the speeches as "tame". No proof was offered that any violence had been contemplated. In fact, Parsons had brought his two small children to the meeting.
On August 19, 1887 the Court sentenced seven of the accused to death, and Oscar Neebe to 15 years imprisonment. After a massive international uproar, the state government relented and commuted the sentences of Michael Schwab and Fielden to life imprisonment. Lingg cheated the hangman by committing suicide in his cell the day before the executions. On November 11th 1887 Parsons, Engel, Spies and Fischer were hanged.
---------------
It also occured to me that for many people this history would be seen as a thing of past - a mere blot in the march of history. After all, we live in a more enlightened age, with the constitutional rights in a democracy, and the "rule of law" governing the social arrangements...
...till one comes across items like these:
2010 Games: Labourers go empty handed?
Migrant Worker Munee in Rural Bihar
...and not just in India, but across the world - numerous labour camps in Dubai, sweatshops in Third World countries...
Third World Slaves Making OUR Bargains to Buy
Posted by
madhukar
at
Saturday, May 01, 2010
2
comments
Labels: Capitalism, Dispencible People, Economic Growth, Footnotes from History, Globalisation, India, Inequality, Suicide Economy, USA
Tuesday, April 13, 2010
Between Hope and Despair (2): Hunger amidst Abundance
I had posted an article by the same title - Between Hope and Despair... a couple of years back... and some vague mental association brought it back today.
Read a news-item Food-shortage forcing children to eat mud today. Some excerpts:
"Under an unusually hot April sun, skinny, hungry children silently poked around on the dusty edges of a stone quarry in Ganne village, 45km east of Allahabad and a 12km walk from the nearest road.
“It tastes like powdered gram, so we eat it,” said Soni, 5, a listless girl with a protruding belly. It’s a learnt experience. Older children such as Soni wait for the excavated moist mud. The younger ones imitate them.
With most families reduced to one or two daily meals of boiled rice and salt—with a watery vegetable on a lucky day—the mud is a free but deadly option at the 20 stone quarries sustaining the poorest villagers.
Eating the mud worsens malnutrition and disease, but these families are not eligible for subsidized food and other state programmes, though each of a family of five earns about Rs400 a month; UP’s official poverty line is Rs435 per person per month."
What an irony, when another news-item informs us: Food grains rotting away in Indian godowns, streets:
"India has godowns to store 16 million tones when it needs almost three times that. What that means is wastage in these times of shortage.
Agricultural scientist Ashok Gulati said, "The total storage capacity is 28 million tonnes .. this leads to losses of 10 – 15%. Translate this into value... that is 6 million tonnes of grains damaged, unfit for human consumption ... it amounts to Rs 8,000 to Rs 10,000 crores annually."
...and one also comes across news-items like these:
along with one like this:
I have experienced this irony in the microcosm of life I live in - the XLRI Campus. Here we have a reasonably well-off educated community, secluded from the rest of the world, and even families of "domestic help" living in the out-houses are much better off than their counterparts elsewhere. Their kids go to schools, play in the campus with other kids, they have TVs at home - some even have air-coolers fitted in their windows....
About two years back, on an early morning, while in my balcony, I saw these two small girls diligently and furtively looking for something from the ground below. I found their innocent seriousness and concentration quite delightful - and trigger-happy as I am, clicked a photograph.
Suddenly they looked up and saw me, and became diffident and apprehensive. When I smiled and asked them what were they looking for, they became slightly relaxed. One of them mentioned a name, and then explained that it is a wild weed. What will you do with that, I asked.
I still remember her matter-of-fact reply, "Amma will cook it for our meal."
just about 100 meters away, in the students' hostel mess, everyday a huge amount of un-eaten food is thrown away, wasted...
As the 12 Myths about Hunger mentions:
"Abundance, not scarcity, best describes the world's food supply. Enough wheat, rice and other grains are produced to provide every human being with 3,200 calories a day. That doesn't even count many other commonly eaten foods: vegetables, beans, nuts, root crops, fruits, grass-fed meats, and fish. Enough food is available to provide at least 4.3 pounds of food per person a day worldwide: two and half pounds of grain, beans and nuts, about a pound of fruits and vegetables, and nearly another pound of meat, milk and eggs- enough to make most people fat! The problem is that many people are too poor to buy readily available food."
Posted by
madhukar
at
Tuesday, April 13, 2010
3
comments
Labels: B-Schools, Hunger, India, Inequality, Poverty
Monday, November 23, 2009
Alchemy of Inequity - A Photo Essay
A picture is equal to a 1000 words - or so it is said!
Here are 23 pictures from Alchemy of Inequity: Resistence and Repression in India's Mines - A Photographic Enquiry...
... a story, one may say... 






















Posted by
madhukar
at
Monday, November 23, 2009
1 comments
Labels: Access Denied, Dispencible People, Economic Development, Economic Growth, environment, India, Inequality, Suicide Economy, terrorism
Thursday, January 15, 2009
India Inc. vs. "Mera Bharat"
Few News Items which came out during last couple of days:
Modi PM material for Anil Ambani, Sunil Mittal
...As the fourth edition of the Vibrant Gujarat Global Investors Summit drew to a close at Ahmedabad on Tuesday, corporate India, shedding its usual reticence, hailed the BJP leader’s (Narendra Modi's) stewardship and went to the extent of putting the "prime ministerial class" stamp on him.
ADAG chairman Anil Ambani, while addressing the valedictory session of the meet, was effusive in his praise of Mr Modi’s leadership. "Narendrabhai has done good for Gujarat and what will happen if he leads the nation," he said. "Gujarat has seen progress in all the fields under his leadership. Now, imagine what will happen to the country if he gets the opportunity to lead it," he said and added, "Person like him should be the next leader of the country"....
Bharti Group CMD Sunil Mittal also showered encomiums. "Chief minister Modi is known as a CEO, but he is actually not a CEO, because he is not running a company or a sector. He is running a state and can also run the nation," he said.
....Both Mr Mittal and Mr Anil Ambani described Mr Modi as the "future leader of the country," given his "capacity to dream with open eyes" and "drive to achieve the results." The younger Ambani asserted that Mr Modi’s achievements in leading Gujarat to an industrialised state had made him "a proud Indian and a proud Gujarati." He said the way he had transformed Gujarat, he could change the complexion of the country as and when he takes over its reins.
Tata Group boss Ratan Tata led the corporates in lauding Mr Modi’s track record. "I have to say that today there is no state like Gujarat. Under Mr Modi’s leadership, Gujarat is head and shoulders above any state," Mr Tata...
Modi’s ‘Taj Mahal’ to displace 35,000 families, says IIM-A study
They say its Modi’s ‘Taj Mahal’, but the Sabarmati Riverfront Development Project, which is expected to attract maximum attention during the Vibrant Gujarat Global Investors’ Summit 2009, will displace around 35,000 odd families from the riverbed and the surrounding areas, according to a study conducted by the Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad (IIM-A).
Navdeep Mathur, a professor at IIM-A, said: "We conducted this study as part of the PGP-PMP course on displacement and rehabilitation issues in the governance. According to the interaction with community leaders and activists, we came to know that nearly 35,000 families will be affected".
Mathur’s team visited the riverbed area in October, followed by a field visit two weeks ago in January. He added: “There is no clarity on the counting of project affected families. We found out that the there was little or no communication with the communities”.
The survey of NGOs - Action Aid and Sabarmati Nagarik Adhikar Manch - and social activists stated that about 35,000 families will be affected, which is in stark contrast to the 4,400 figure given by the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) initially. The locals of the riverbed, with the help of activists, had filed a petition against the AMC in the Gujarat High Court.
Elsewhere, a news item - Half of Vibrant Gujarat Goes to Sleep Empty Stomach mentions some statistics:
etc.
Postcript: A couple of friends wrote back on the above post that it would be fairer comparison if Gujarat's hunger record is placed along side the national average.
That is a legitimate query, and will certainly help in forming a more balanced view about its growth or otherwise. The India State Hunger Index from IFPRI report is as below. Among 17 states, Gujarat ranks 13 - above Chhatisgarh, Bihar, Jharkhand and Madhya Pradesh
Posted by
madhukar
at
Thursday, January 15, 2009
7
comments
Labels: Capitalism, Corporations, Dispencible People, Hunger, India, Inequality, Poverty
Tuesday, August 12, 2008
Left Behind...
In one of his speeches, Bill Clinton said: ""The opposition to globalization in the world is rooted in the feeling of some people that they are left out, left behind..."
Since he mentioned this as a "feeling" of "some" people, I began making a list:
No, it is not complete, so help me to complete it...
Post-script: Thanks for adding to the list. I have included them in italics
Posted by
madhukar
at
Tuesday, August 12, 2008
9
comments
Labels: Capitalism, Dispencible People, Economic Growth, Globalisation, Inequality, Poverty
Sunday, July 20, 2008
India's Rural Energy Security - Factsheet
Indian economy is growing and needs more and more energy to maintain its growth (at least growth of that part of India, which is growing). Therefore, there is much discussions about the Energy Security needs of India. In fact, this coming week the current UPA government may fall (or survive) for the option it has chosen.
However, there is also a need to differentiate between the urban and rural energy security, to have a meaningful public debate/discourse on the issue.
Here are some facts, which I could collect:

- A news item about load-shedding in Karnataka last year says:
"The State Government will not enforce load-shedding in urban areas in March and April as students will be preparing for their examinations, Minister for Energy H.D. Revanna has said."
[which may sound strange if one knows that of the 47,000 schools in Karnataka, more than 41,000 are in rural area]
- Similarly, a recent news item from Maharashtra, mentions:
"In highly industrialised urban areas, the load shedding will be from four to seven hours. In other urban areas, it will be from seven to 8.5 hours, while in the rural areas it will be for 11 hours, according to an official release said here today."
"Grid connection remains the most favoured approach to rural electrification for the majority of rural households. Indeed the latest government programme for rural electrification, the RGGVY, focuses in particular on a vast expansion of the existing grid to reach all villages by 2012. Whilst state utilities typically report an average cost of supply at around Rs.3/kWh most studies... suggest that cost of delivery to rural areas can be around three times generation costs. A recent estimate for a Gujarat case study, based on Gujarat Electricity Board data, put the true cost of delivery to rural areas at over Rs.9/kWh.
As the distance from the grid increases, the cost of grid connection rises considerably. It increases costs by roughly Rs1/kWh per kilometre of expansion to individual villages. Typically grid tariffs for poor rural households range from Rs.0-10/month for the poorest households and Rs.0-130/month for remaining domestic customers. These charges typically lie well below the cost of supply and are sustained through redistributive policies, tariff cross-subsidies and financial relief to loss-making State electricity boards (SEB)."
"The dependability of rural areas on electricity is less as compared to the dependability of urban areas. The agricultural sector normally does not require power for 24 hours. This concept has also been accepted by the Hon. Commission during the discussions on the tariff proposals wherein a maximum of 13 hours use per day is considered for agricultural pumps."
- 91% of the 0.7mn schools are located in rural areas
- of the approx 28,000 integrated higher secondary schools (i.e., from primary to higher secondary), about 62% are in villages
- overall about 87% of India's schools are in rural areas

"...there are 42.12 million enterprises in the country engaged in different economic activities other than crop production and plantation. Out of which, 25.81 million enterprises (61.3%) are in the rural areas and 16.31 million enterprises (38.7%) in the urban areas." These rural non-farm enterprises also account for 51% of employment.
So, are there any options?
...of course, there are!!! - but that will need another post!...
Posted by
madhukar
at
Sunday, July 20, 2008
4
comments
Labels: Access Denied, Economic Development, Energy, India, Inequality
Sunday, July 06, 2008
"...suffer in the interest of the nation!"
In 1948, Jawaharlal Nehru, in a public speech to those, who were to be displced by the Hirakud Dam, is supposed to have said:
"If you are to suffer, you should suffer in the interest of the nation."
He may have never envisaged that his words will get operationalised by India not having a comprehensive National Rehabilitation Policy for the DIDs (development-induced-displaced) for many decades, and then developing one, which would bypass those who get affected by "development"...
Much later, in 1974, the then Prime-Minister Indira Gandhi wrote to Baba Amte in a letter:
"I am most unhappy that development projects displace tribal people from their habitat, especially as project authorities do not always take care to properly rehabilitate the affected population. But sometimes there is no alternative and we have to go ahead in the larger interest…."
...and so, for another couple of decades, India - and its sufferers "in the interest of the nation" - continued to live with "no alternative"...
Meanwhile, India built 3,300 large dams, and a study by Indian Institute of Public Administration, suggested that on average a large dam displaces around 44,000 people... which adds upto a whopping 145mn displaced people!!!... and by large dams alone (we - I - don’t have data about the number of victims of development due to highways, large manufacturing plants, infrastructure projects, city beautification projects, etc.)
The experts, ranging from Arundhati Roy to NC Saxena (Secretary, Planning Commission), however, estimate that the number would be around 50mn.... Maybe 80mn... Anyway...
Over period of time, however, India did developed a National Policy for Rehabilitation and Resettlement... Starting from a draft in 1993-94 to a comprehensive policy in 2007. The opening statement of the 1994 draft of the National Rehabilitation Policy also acknowledged that the inhabitants of remote and backward areas and the tribal regions are the ones who are most affected by the "developmental projects":
"It is expected that there will be large-scale investments, both on account of internal generation of capital and increased inflow of foreign investments, thereby creating an enhanced demand for land to be provided within a shorter time-span in an increasingly competitive market-ruled economic structure. Majority of our mineral resources… are located in the remote and backward areas mostly inhabited by tribals".
Though the overlap of tribal land and mineral-rich area was never mentioned again in the R&R policies of 2004 and 2007, but the National Rehabilitation & Resttlement Policy 2007 did stipulate that to those affected by the projects should be consulted in drafting plans to rehabilitate them. To quote:
"...the Administrator for Rehabilitation and Resettlement shall prepare a draft scheme or plan for the rehabilitation and resettlement of the affected families after consultation with the representatives of the affected families including women and the representative of the requiring body."
The 2007 R&R Policy also stipulates that:
"6.14.3 The draft scheme or plan may be made known locally by wide publicity in the affected area and the resettlement area (or areas) in such manner as may be prescribed by the appropriate Government.
6.15.1 The draft rehabilitation and resettlement scheme or plan shall also be discussed in gram sabhas in rural areas and in public hearings in urban and rural areas where gram sabhas don't exist."
...and incase of Scheduled Areas (i.e., the tribal and NE regions):
"7.21.2 The concerned gram sabha or the panchayats at the appropriate level in the Scheduled Areas under Schedule V of the Constitution or as the case may be, Councils in the Schedule VI Areas shall be consulted in all Cases of land acquisition in such areas including land acquisition in cases of urgency, before issue of a notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 or any other Act of the Union or a State for the time being in force under which land acquisition is undertaken..."
All this sounds very hopeful - that the interests of those affected are safe-guarded, that they can have a say in their lives... Till one reads stories like this (from page 48-49 of Caterpillar and the Mahua Flower):
"That companies are coming by the dozen to Chhattisgarh to mine its mineral wealth is hardly surprising. The state is rich in natural resources, with abundant deposits of iron, gold, tin, diamonds, coal, uranium, bauxite, corundum, dolomite, copper, limestone and other minerals. It’s estimated that the state has 35,000 million tonnes of coal, 2,336 million tonnes of iron ore, 3,580 million tonnes of limestone, 606 million tonnes of dolomite, 96 million tonnes of bauxite, and 29 million tonnes of cassiterite. With such bounty, Chhattisgarh accounts for over 13 percent of India’s total mineral production, worth around Rs 4,000 crores a year. Most importantly, 23 percent of the country’s iron-ore deposits are located here...
....While the government cheered about the MoUs with Tata and Essar, the locals were curious about the agreements’ terms. How much land had been given to these two steel giants? Whose land was it? Would tribal land be confiscated? Would there be compensation, rehabilitation, or employment for the locals at these units? But no replies were forthcoming from the government on these issues.
MoUs have always been considered as public documents but a veil of secrecy hung over the government’s agreements with Tata and Essar. When the people demanded a copy of the MoUs under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, the answer they obtained was both shocking and surprising: it was stated that a condition in the MoU prevented the government from revealing it to a third party!"
..."a third party"!!!??
On second thoughts, the "you" who was asked to suffer for the interest of the nation, was obviously not seen as a part of "the nation"...
Sources:
Posted by
madhukar
at
Sunday, July 06, 2008
7
comments
Labels: Dispencible People, Economic Development, Economic Growth, India, Indian history, Inequality
Friday, June 27, 2008
A Rich Nation of Poor People
In the first couple of years of the 21st century, something changed drastically and radically in India - and her relations with her populace and environment... India redefined its "tryst with destiny"
On January 26th, the Republic Day of 2001, the then President KR Narayanan refered to the "dilemmas of development" which India must carefully think through. He said:
"Let it not be said by future generations that the Indian Republic has been built on the destruction of green earth and innocent tribals who have been living there for centuries. Let it not be said of India, that this great Republic, in it surry to develop itself, is devastating the mother earth, and uprooting our tribal population.... The developmental path we have adapted is hurting them and threatening their very existence.... While the nation must benefit from the exploitation of these minerals resources, we will have to take into consideration the questions of environmental protection and rights of the tribals..."
Less than 3 years later, on November 1 2003, in a speech to the 19th World Mining Congress, the then President APJ Kalam contradicted the concerns of his predecessor:
""We should work for increasing the productivity from 0.5 tonnes per man year to 5 tonnes per man-year in underground coal mines using long wall mining and from 15 tonnes per man-year to 30 tonnes per man-year in open cast mines.... The fecilitation of project through provision of land, infrastructural development, community development, etc., can be done by the government agencies while the investments in the mines and associated technological inputs can come from the private sector... In addition, the private sector must have freedon to run the mine in a cost-effective manner..."
The implications of this U-turn can be viewed in perspective, if one recalls these statistics from an earlier posting:
...and just to add to these, some more facts:
So how has India redefined its "tryst with destiny"?
We have become a Rich Nation...
...with Poor People, and an increasingly Depleted Environment!!
Posted by
madhukar
at
Friday, June 27, 2008
0
comments
Labels: Dispencible People, Economic Development, India, Inequality, Suicide Economy
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
Global Famine and Global Feast
Prof Gaddeswarup - one of the many blog-personas, I have met, conversed and related with in this space during last couple of years - sent me a link today to an article about the current food crisis I had blogged about earlier (Global Hunger: The Next Stage of Globalisation...
What struck me was this interesting graph in the report:
Apparently, the food production has increased 3-fold during since 1961, while the world population has slightly doubled from 3bn to 6bn+... and prices have gone down singinificantly (inspite of the current peak)
... and yet we have a "food crisis"!! why?
Which reminded me of an Austrian documentary "We Feed the World", which I had seen some months back. The film was about globalisation and food: "Every day in Vienna the amount of unsold bread sent back to be disposed of is enough to supply Austria's second-largest city, Graz. Around 350,000 hectares of agricultural land, above all in Latin America, are dedicated to the cultivation of soybeans to feed Austria's livestock while one quarter of the local population starves. Every European eats ten kilograms a year of artificially irrigated greenhouse vegetables from southern Spain, which results in water shortages."
The image, which remained stuck in my mind for days, was that of a truck-load of perfectly edible food being dumped in the garbage yard... It was a criminal waste.
The driver of the truck says, "...we take away about 2mn kilos of bread every year, and there is nothing wrong with them. It's no more than 2 day old, fit for anybody to eat... I always drive the same route, I see old people stopping and staring, because they just can't believe what we are doing."
Apparently, the "food crisis" is there because much of what is produced goes waste in the value chain...
One oft-mentioned aspect is the waste that happens by the time the produce reaches the consumer... Mostly prevalent in the developing countries.
For example, in March this year, in India, the Minister of State for Food Processing Industries (FPI) Subodh Kant Sahay, informed the parliament that as much as as Rs.58,000 worth of grains get wasted due to lack of adequate post-harvest infrastructure, i.e., due to lack of cold chains, transportation and proper storage facilities, etc.
What is, however, not highlighted is the food wastage that happens after it reaches the consumer... specially in the developed countries/economies.
So here are some snapshots which I could gather from the net:
Somewhat related earlier posts:
Posted by
madhukar
at
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
2
comments
Labels: Access Denied, Farming but Famished, Globalisation, Hunger, Inequality, Poverty
Sunday, April 13, 2008
Ekalavya gets into a B-School...
We continue with our Parable of Modern-Day Ekalavya...
Thanks to the recent Supreme Court judgement, Ekalavya had applied and got into a B-school through the "OBC quota" seats
...and immediately hit the glass ceiling described as "Criteria specified in Category VI" in the Supreme Court judgement!!
He could get the admission, because he had qualified, because he belonged to the "reserved" OBC category, and because he did not belong to the "creamy layer" criteria specified in the judgement.
His parents did not fall in the categories of Constitutional Posts, i.e.,
He was also not the progeny of those falling into the Service Category or the category of Armed Forces including Paramilitary Forces, i.e.,
In any case the above would not have qualified for reservations due to the "Criteria specified in Category VI"...
(yes, yes, I am coming to what this criteria is... Let there be some suspence to the story! ;0)
This "Criteria specified in Category VI", however, did apply to the sons and daughters of other categories.
For instance, it applied to sons and daughters of Professional Class and those engaged in Trade and Industry, e.g.,
...and it also applied to the progeny of the Property Owners, e.g.,
etc.
But, what was this "Criteria specified in Category VI"?
This was the final "Income/Wealth Test", meant to exclude the "creamy layer" - it excluded people coming from families with sufficient financial means. Based on the famous Indra Sawhney (Mandal) SC Judgement, this criteria excluded sons and daughters whose parents had an annual income of more than Rs 2.5lacs (Rs, 250,000).
Happily and fortunately, this criteria, which would have excluded him from admissions, did not apply to Ekalavya. He did not belong to the "creamy layer". His parents did not hold Constitutional Posts, or were in the Service Category. They were also not in the Professional Class, or engaged in Trade and Industry, with an annual income exceeding Rs 2.5lacs. And, of course, they owned no property, as described in the judgement.
But Ekalavya was crestfallen and dejected - actually shattered - when I met him.
"There is no way, I can get into this B-School," he told me.
"But why?", I asked him. "You have qualified, and you are not in the "creamy layer"."
"But where will I get the money to pay the fee?"
"What's the problem?", I said. "You can get education loan from a bank, can't you? Everyone says how simple education loans are nowadays. And you can pay that back once you get the job. Look at the average B-school salaries these days!"
"But do you know? The IIMs almost doubled up their fee just a week before the Judgement." he spat. "It is close to Rs 10lacs now... Other will follow soon, I am sure."
"How does that matter to you?", I could not comprehend. "What is Rs. 10lacs? You can get the education loan, and pay it back when you get the job. After all, your salary package will compensate for the fee hike."
"Yes, this is what everyone tells me. Once in the job, you can easily cover your costs." he said. "But you need money to get into, and through, a B-school, don't you?."
It was then that he shared the glass ceiling - or the Combo of B-school Fee Hike and India Banks' Association's Model Education Loan Scheme for Pursuing Higher Education in India, which is followed by all banks with minor modifications.
"Not being from the "creamy layer"", he said, "I need to take a loan of at least more than Rs 7.5lacs (The max recommended limit is Rs 10lacs) to pay the fee. I also need money to live and eat during those two years. But that loan requires as, the document says, "co-obligation of parents together with tangible collateral security of suitable value"."
tangible collateral security of suitable value!! What is that!!?
I read through the Model Education Loan Scheme about the collateral security. It read:
"The security can be in the form of land/ building/ Govt. securities/ Public Sector Bonds/Units of UTI, NSC, KVP, life policy, gold, shares/mutual fund units/debentures, bank deposit in the name of student/ parent/ guardian or any other third party with suitable margin."
Ekalavya glared at me. "Please tell me,", he challenged. "...all you who keep talking about "creamy layer". I am not the "creamy layer" and therefore, I am entitled to what you call "reservations". But also because I am not the "creamy layer", the banks would not give me loan to see me through my education."
No! I have no anwers for Ekalavya. Maybe only a solace that, OBC or not, - on the income criteria - more than 95% people in this country do no belong to the "creamy layer"!
Posted by
madhukar
at
Sunday, April 13, 2008
8
comments
Labels: Access Denied, B-Schools, Education, Inequality, Poverty, Reservations
Thursday, April 10, 2008
"Alternative Perspective" on Reservations/ OBC/ Merit/ Quota/ Discrimination, etc
Today the Supreme Court gave the verdict upholding the 27% reservations for the OBCs in IITs, IIMs and other Central educational institutions but excluded the creamy layer (i.e., the children of constitutional functionaries including the President, judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts, members of the Union Public Service Commission, Groups A and B or Class I or II officers of the All-India Central and State services and children of public sector employees) from the benefit.
Just thought it appropriate to share the past 14-15 postings on:
Alternative Perspective on Reservation, meritocracy, OBC quota, etc.
(click to access)
To me, rightly or wrongly, this makes perfect sense... After all, you have to change the system to change the human dynamics in that system.
However, lest the "manufactured merit" churned out by the coaching centers feel that "their" rightful seats (due to the freak circumstances of their birth, and the coaching institutes) are being taken away from them, here is a clarification:
"In the 2007-08 budget, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram allocated Rs.26.98 billion for central educational institutions under the HRD ministry providing for 54 percent increase in the number of seats.
According to officials, in the budget for 2008-09 an allocation of about Rs.25.22 billion has been made for central universities - IITs, IIMs, NITs etc, for the purpose.
Following protests from various quarters, an Oversight Committee recommended a 54 percent expansion (over three years) in central educational institutions so that the number of general seats is not reduced."
The SC judgement vindicates what Michael Young - who coined the term Meritocracy - wrote in 2001 (I had quoted it earlier):
"It is good sense to appoint individual people to jobs on their merit. It is the opposite when those who are judged to have merit of a particular kind harden into a new social class without room in it for others.
Ability of a conventional kind, which used to be distributed between the classes more or less at random, has become much more highly concentrated by the engine of education.
A social revolution has been accomplished by harnessing schools and universities to the task of sieving people according to education's narrow band of values.
With an amazing battery of certificates and degrees at its disposal, education has put its seal of approval on a minority, and its seal of disapproval on the many who fail to shine from the time they are relegated to the bottom streams.... The new class has the means at hand, and largely under its control, by which it reproduces itself."
Posted by
madhukar
at
Thursday, April 10, 2008
0
comments
Labels: B-Schools, Education, Inequality, Reservations
Sunday, April 06, 2008
My "Encounters" with Maoists/ Naxals
Well, to be honest, I did not have any such "direct" encounters... only some "vicarious" ones
One of the most recent ones was today, when I finished reading Sudeep Chakravarty's travelogue "Red Sun: Travels through the Naxalite Country"...
For those who have not read the book, it is highly recommended. It breaks through the veil of denial, which the aspiring urban middle-class, the "India Shining" media, the politicians and bureaucrats tend to deny/under-represent in the public awareness/ discourse... Even when this growing phenomenon is publicly noted, it is seen/described as a regional problem; the news gets covered in the regional newspapers/editions...
However, if one pays attention, the phenomenon is growing, and becoming increasingly noticeable. I tried to find out and in Google News, there were 210 news items on "naxal maoist" in last one week....
And as the timeline shows, the trend has shot up in last 3-4 years...
In any case, when the Prime Minister of India describes "Maoists" as the "single largest internal security threat" (as he did last year) - and accepts that 165 of the 600-odd districts are affected by this threat - then, if you are travelling into the hinterlands of India, the chances are more than one-in-four that you have a direct or vicarious brush with this "threat"
(These 165 districts, incidentally, are spread across 14 Indian states. Among the other non-Maoist-effected states are the otherwise-troubled J&K, Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur, Nagaland, Assam and Meghalaya - thus, leaving only eight Indian states as "peaceful")
Reading the book, brought back these memories of my "encounters" during last few months. During last couple of months, I had a chance of travelling across the interiors of Jharkhand, Orissa and Chattisgarh in connection to some assessment of NGOs... This was also an opportunity to cross-check the official line that the Maoists - described as "these thugs/ anti-national elements/ criminals" etc. - resist "development" (industrialisation, mining projects, large dams, investments, job-creation, building of infrastruction, etc.), because they feeds on poverty, misery and lack of development and so on.
Here are some snapshots from my "vicarious" experiences:
Snapshot 1:
I was in Hazaribagh (Jharkhand). My hosts were one of the largest - and oldest - NGO in the region (Bihar & Jharkhand). The NGO was started by four engineering graduates in 1971, who were inspired by the ideas of Gandhi, Binoba Bhave and Jai Prakash Narain. They had continued working in programs related to socio-economic development (e.g., supporting micro-entrepreneurship), health & sanitation, education, community mobilisation through forming SHGs, etc... And they covered virtually the whole of Jharkhand and Bihar.
"Just out of curiosity," I asked, "all that you are doing is in the region heavily infested by Maoists. And all that you are doing goes against what these people stand for. Your funding comes from foreign, mostly foreign donors, and your work helps people becoming self-sufficient... And so, they will not have any reason to join the Maoist revolution. Don't you come in conflict with the Maoists?"
"Not really," one of the founders told me, "yes, sometime they accost our people. But you only have to tell them that you are part of "Samiti" - that's how we are known - and they let us do our work. We may not agree with them, but they do agree with what we are doing.... No, there is no conflict of objectives."
Snapshot 2:This was in the interiors of Chattisgarh. My hostess, an old self-effacing missionary sister, managed an NGO which had worked in the four districts of the state in area of healthcare since 1969. Over a period of time, they had established more than 90 Rural Health Centers (serving 1200 villages), managed by registered nurses, and supported by Mitanis - the Village Level Healthworkers - who were trained by the organisation. It had pioneered a Community Health Insurance scheme, at an yearly premium of "2kg of rice", which provides comprehensive healthcare to more than 90,000 poor and tribals in the region.
The focus of their activities, however, goes beyond the just the physical health. It is a holistic approach, which delves deeper into the causes of ill-health, and deals with them through people-centred activities like leadership training, health education, livelihood-promotion, formation of self-help-groups and tackling the various antecednts of malnutrition. It is more like a social movement, than just a healthcare venture...
When I asked the sister the same question, she said, "No, we never had any problems with them. Maybe, we are not in "The Corridor". But even if we were in their area, why would there be any problems? We, these women in the SHGs, have often achieved the same aims, like fair disbursal of money from government schemes, social justice in a caste-ridden village, through more peaceful means." She thought about it, and then added, "we do have problems of wild elephants, though."
That was January 26th, a very cold day in Pathalgaon. We celebrated the Republic Day by hoisting the Tri-colour...
Snapshot 3:"You see that hill over there? Beyond that is "The Corridor"," Mr Meher - the "Public Relations Officer" of the NGO I was visiting - mentioned in passing, as if he was describing the location of a roadside dhaba. It was early morning, and I had gone to see the "innovative schools" which the organisation runs in the interiors of Orissa. These classes were held in the premises of the local government schools.
"No government teacher comes to teach here," Mr Meher told me, "but we use their building before the school timings. We recruit a local educated youth to teach the basics of reading and maths, and about health, hygiene, environment, their rights and responsibilities, etc."
There was, of course, an incentive to attend for the kids - free soya milk and bread... which, of course, was also a great attraction for many to even bring their toddler siblings to the school :0)
Later is the day, when we were returning, I asked him about the Maoists. "Your activities cover the whole of Orissa. Even though an NGO, you are almost like a mid-size private-sector company with a "turnover" of Rs. 250cr and employing 1200-1500 professionals" - they are into everything from micro-finance, micro-insurance (with tie-ups with some of the well known corporate insurance companies), micro-enterprise, social development (from running a home for destitute women to SHGs for village craftsmen... including a chain of retail outlets for the produce from the SHGs) - "You are trying to bring income, prosperity, self-sufficiency at grassroot level. Doesn't your work come in conflict with the Maoists?"
He weighed the question, looked at me quizically, and said, "We are doing things which are good for people. Why would we come in conflict with anyone? Yes, there were instances when one of our people were caught by them. But we explained, and they released him."...
Snapshot 4:
I was packing my bags to return the next day, and glanced at the headlines of local edition of Indian Express. Its headline screamed of about the murder of an ex-surpanch by the Maoists/Ultras - he was supposed to be a police informer. What caught my eyes was this line in the news:
"The ultras left behind the posters in which they warned against sale of liquor, trafficking of timber and encroachment of tribal land".
!!!?
I was/am confused. Do I sympathise with the violent "ultras"? NO!... There are better - non-violent - ways...
On the other hand, shouldn't such posters be distributed by the government/ state to its populace?...
We live in confusing times...
Posted by
madhukar
at
Sunday, April 06, 2008
8
comments
Labels: Dispencible People, Economic Development, India, Inequality, Poverty
Sunday, March 30, 2008
East is East, and West and West...
...and never the twain shall meet !!
Rudyard Kipling might have written his ballad for modern India.
Omakar Goswami's CERG Advisory compiled detailed data from Census 2001 on rural India, going down to the level of its around 600 districts, tehsils and villages. The findings were published in Business World about 2 years back
The data ranked every single Indian district in terms of household ownership of, and access to eleven assets or amenities. These were:
- whether a household has a bank or post-office account,
- whether it has a permanent or pucca house,
- whether it has an electricity connection,
- whether it owns a television set,
- whether it owns a scooter or motorcycle,
- whether it uses LPG for cooking,
- whether its drinking water source is either in the homestead or within 500 metres,
- whether it has a separate kitchen within the homestead,
- whether it has a separate toilet,
- whether it has a separate enclosed bathing place and
- whether whether it has a telephone.
Needless to say, if the majority of households have access to these assets and amenities, the region would be more economically prosperous.
What emerged was this picture:

Is there a learning in this map?... Think about it!!!
Update: On second thoughts, here are some indications....
A Map of Mineral Resources and Forest Cover in India:

A report Rich Land, Poor People by Center for Science and Environment, noted that:
Earlier in the report, is a paragraph:
"Minerals, however, are essential for a nation which stands on the threshold of a promising future, and must be extracted. Which means the land, its resources and people must make way for the miners. Enamoured by mining industry's promises of progress, Indian planners and lawmakers have achieved this with clinical and brutal precision. Forests are razed, waterways polluted and clogged, farmland transformed into wasted tracts, and mining dust hangs neavy in the air. As for the people, they are summarily evicted with little prospect or promise of compensation and rehabilitation.... Most mining areas of the nation remain mired in grinding poverty and deprivation."
... which perhaps may explain this last map:
Posted by
madhukar
at
Sunday, March 30, 2008
0
comments
Labels: Dispencible People, Economic Growth, India, Inequality, Poverty, Suicide Economy